Manhattan's Best Candy Store

Some Manhattan sugar runs require a strategy: you either hit the chocolate temples near Rockefeller (shoutout to Brigitte and that deep, adult hot chocolate) or you embrace the Lower East Side chaos of Economy Candy, where the bulk taffy bins whisper your name. I've done both in one afternoon, and my dentist is still mad.

But the real question isn't fancy versus nostalgic—it's whether you want to stuff a giant Reese's cup in Times Square or just get a perfect pistachio gelato uptown. Either way, you're winning.

Just don't check your step count after.

Ray's Candy Store

Highlights
Real Ray, real egg creams
Oreo milkshake hits the spot
Fried Oreos worth returning for

Ray's Candy Store is the kind of place that makes you feel like you've stepped into a time capsule, and I mean that in the best way. Real Ray himself was behind the counter, whipping up an egg cream that tasted like pure nostalgia. The Oreo milkshake hit the spot on a hot afternoon, thick and creamy with just the right cookie crunch. But the fried Oreos? Those are worth coming back for, no question. Crispy, warm, and somehow lighter than they sound. The place is cluttered, a little chaotic, and completely charming. If you want authenticity over polish, Ray's delivers every time.

You might also want to check out the best soul food restaurants in Manhattan.

M&M'S New York

Highlights
Customizable M&M’s wall
Massive multi-floor layout
NYC-themed souvenir selection
Fun photo-worthy moments
Great for families and tourists

M&M'S New York is basically a candy theme park, and I cannot lie. The customizable M&M's wall had me spending way too long picking out little letters and colors for my own bag, but it's so worth it. The place spans multiple floors, so you'll wander up and down looking at NYC-themed souvenirs that are heavy on the Statue of Liberty and yellow taxi vibes. There are plenty of photo-worthy moments, too. Families with kids will be in heaven, and tourists seem to lose their minds over the giant candy displays. It's not subtle, but it's a joy ride through chocolate.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in West Village.

Teuscher Fifth Avenue

Highlights
Champagne truffles are wedding favorites
Friendly staff, helpful service
Pricey but undeniably tasty
Boutique high-end chocolate selection

Teuscher Fifth Avenue is the kind of place that feels like a special privilege. The champagne truffles? I get why weddings always have them around. They're delicate, boozy, and deeply satisfying. The staff here was genuinely friendly, not the stiff, fancy vibe you might expect from a boutique. They helped me pick out a few pieces and I will admit the price tag made me wince for a sec. But then I tasted one and realized, okay, it's worth it. Everything is refined and polished, from the chocolates to the service. If you have a few bucks to splurge, step in and treat yourself. Just don't look at your bank balance later.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Williamsburg.

Varsano's Chocolate

Highlights
Incredible citrus and caramel options
Kind, patient, wonderful owner
Outstanding white chocolate quality
Reliable special orders, always on time
Five-star service and craftsmanship

Varsano's Chocolate is a special find. I walked in with no clear plan and walked out with my new favorite white chocolate, which is saying something because I'm usually a dark chocolate guy. The citrus and caramel options? Absolutely incredible. But what really made this visit memorable for me was the owner. Kind, patient, and so wonderful to talk to. He walked me through everything without rushing me. Plus, I heard that he handles special orders reliably and on time, which is such a nice thing in this busy city. The craftsmanship here is five-star, and the service matches. This is a place that treats chocolate like art, but with warmth.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Hoboken.

Hershey's Chocolate World

Highlights
Paradise for chocolate lovers
Interactive, immersive retail experience
Personalized chocolates and NYC souvenirs
Giant Reese's cup stuffing fun
Aromatic, lively Times Square atmosphere

Hershey's Chocolate World in Times Square. It's basically paradise for anyone who likes chocolate, and who's reading a candy and not. The whole place is immersive, from the massive bins of Hershey's Kisses to the interactive displays. One of the favorite things I did was stuff a giant Reese's cup, which sounds silly but is actually a hoot. You can also personalize your own chocolate, which is a fun experience and making some time. The smell of chocolate everywhere is just aromatic. It's lively and crowded, like Times Square times a thousand, but a little chocolate energy goes a long way. Good spot for souvenirs, too.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in East Village.

Venchi Chocolate & Gelato UES

Highlights
Gelato worth every penny
Pistachio flavor is outstanding
Sampling makes choosing easy
Prime grab-and-go spot

On the Upper East Side, Venchi is a grab-and-go spot that actually lives up to its name. I stopped in for a gelato, and the pistachio flavor just stood out. So creamy, so nutty, so right. They let you sample a little bit before you commit, which makes choosing super easy. Honestly, I appreciated that because the options that line up in front of you all look worth trying. It's not a big sit-down place, but you don't need to stay long. You get your gelato, you walk and enjoy it. It's a little on the pricey side but that pistachio flavor justifies every cent. I'll be back.

You might also want to check out the best steakhouse in Manhattan.

La Maison du Chocolat Rockefeller

Highlights
Hot chocolate with adult flavor
Refined, expensive, worth it
Impeccable service from Brigitte
Tastings guide smart purchases
Macarons await future visits

La Maison du Chocolat near Rockefeller Center feels like it knows it's fancy. It's refined, expensive, and honestly, worth it. I had a hot chocolate here that was deep, bold, and completely adult. It was a bitter, sweet and a little bit like the first time. The service is impeccable, too. Brigitte, who helped me at the counter, was so patient explaining the different origins and letting me taste small things so I spent smart. She took the scary out of this fancy. I didn't get to the macarons but they're on my next list. Be prepared to pay, and then be delighted by what you get back.

You might also want to check out the best deli in Manhattan.

Venchi Chocolate & Gelato NOMAD

Highlights
Rich Raspberry Chocoviar hot chocolate
Warm, welcoming counter staff
Beautiful store design
Great chocolate variety
Small but cozy seating

The NOMAD Venchi location is cozy and gorgeous. I walked in for a hot chocolate, and their Raspberry Chocoviar taste blew my mind. It is rich and decadent, not super sweet but deep and fruity. The counter staff were warm, welcoming, and they didn't mind my slow decision making. The store design is beautiful, clean watery lines and chocolate on every side. They have all different types of chocolate bars and sweets, plenty of variety. There are a few small seats inside, which is nice if you want to linger a moment. I sat, sipped, and thought about moving in. A very good spot.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Astoria.

Kreuther Handcrafted Chocolate (at Gabriel Kreuther restaurant)

Highlights
Chocolate next to Michelin star
Profiterole worth every bite
Balanced flavors, not too sweet
Quality chocolate, fair price
Perfect Bryant Park stop

Kreuther Handcrafted Chocolate sits right next to a Michelin-starred restaurant, so you'd expect it to be all fussy, but they keep it approachable. I went for a profiterole which is what you should do. One bite and I almost felt my soul relax. The chocolate is balanced, not too sweet, and the flavors work together in a more subtle, quiet way. It somehow tastes expensive but the price felt fair for what you get. It's also perfect if you're already wandering around Bryant Park and you need a warm, chocolaty pause. I snoozed. A small shop, but it's the kind that makes you think about it for days.

You might also want to check out the best thai restaurant in Manhattan.

Economy Candy

Highlights
Endless nostalgic candy selection
Unique imported finds galore
Affordable souvenir tote bags
Classic taffy in bulk
Friendly, bustling atmosphere

Economy Candy is endlessly nostalgic in the best possible way. I walk in and I'm ten years old again, except I have money now and no one to tell me no. They've got all the classic taffy in bulk, bits and pieces, plus shelves and shelves of unique imported finds that I've never seen anywhere else. It's bustling and a little chaotic but in a friendly way, kind of like a good party. I also picked up a souvenir tote bag that wasn't priced too badly. If you want a serious sugar rush and a walk down memory lane, this is the place. Not fancy, but the real deal.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in Manhattan.

BonBon - A Swedish Candy Co.

Highlights
Fresh, colorful, welcoming candy shop
Friendly staff, speedy service
Delicious desserts and drinks
Fun, playful atmosphere
Worth a return visit

BonBon is exactly what you hope a Swedish candy spot would look like and taste like. Bright colors, fresh signs, and it feels welcoming the second you step in. The staff were super friendly and fast, even when the line started forming behind me. I tried a few desserts and drinks here and they were actually delicious. Sweet, rich, and playful. The vibe is fun and light, almost like a candy games for grown-ups. Not too much seating, but you're not going to want to sit when there's this much to look at. Honestly, I saw myself coming back just to work through the entire menu one by one. Better than fine.

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Manhattan.

The Sweet Shop NYC

Highlights
Best ice cream in NYC
Friendly owner Matthew
Tons of flavor options
PB&J sundae perfection
Candy tastings available

The West Park Shop NYC might actually have the best ice cream you can find in Manhattan. I say that with some confidence because I've had a lot of ice cream. Owner Matthew is legit friendly, he talked to me about his flavor combinations like a proud dad. The PB&J sundae is absolute perfection, by the way. It's like a classic lunch turned into dessert and it works. They've got flavors for days, plenty of options. Additionally, they do candy tastings, which felt like fun and aimed at the little kid in me. It's informal, welcoming, and the quality is real. A proper after-you-go spot.

You might also want to check out the best chinese restaurant in Manhattan.